Upward view of downtown Chicago blue skies

DRI is the Largest Bar Association of Civil Defense Attorneys and In-House Counsel

Seminars & Webinars

Announcements

DRI National Poll: Average Americans Not Yet Willing to Entrust Their Legal Fate to Computers or Non-Lawyer Assistants

  • Published February 20, 2018
    Modified July 09, 2020

 

CHICAGO ­– (February 19, 2018)—The only national poll of average Americans on the civil justice system has found the majority of them are not willing to rely on either computers or non-lawyer assistants for legal advice. This is the conclusion obtained in the latest DRI National Poll on the Civil Justice System conducted in December by AmeriSpeak, a polling firm of NORC at the University of Chicago.

The poll results are highly relevant to the legal profession and the judicial system given the conversation surrounding the application of artificial intelligence and the rise of low-cost legal counseling services that employ non-lawyer assistants.

“There are many consumers of legal services in the U.S.” says DRI president John Kuppens. “Because most of the debate about the justice system takes place among lawyers, jurists, and policy-makers, DRI thinks it important to find out what the average person thinks  about our civil justice system. You would probably get different answers to our questions if they were being asked of corporate purchases of legal services.”

When asked if they would be comfortable relying on legal advice provided by a computer, two-thirds (66.7%) of those polled said “No.” When asked the same question about receiving legal advice from someone who did not attend law school, the response was overwhelmingly negative (85.4%). Of those that responded “yes” to either question, their confidence was limited to transactional services like preparing a will or handling a real estate closing.

In another question regarding artificial intelligence, respondents were asked if they would rather have their cases decided by a computer generated formula, a judge, a jury, or an arbitrator who may or may not have legal training, The vast majority (87.1%) preferred a judge or jury. Only 5.1% would opt for a computer generated formula.

“This underscores the importance of the DRI poll,” said Steve Puiszis, chair of DRI’s Center for Law and Public Policy. “Without the science of professional polling, any conversation about consumer preferences on legal services and other aspects of the judicial system are just a matter of speculation or personal bias. The DRI poll is a scientific reflection of popular opinion.”

Puiszis noted “there are important societal questions reflected in the DRI poll. All stakeholders in our civil justice system should be concerned about access to justice for those who need it. Corporations generally don’t have access to justice problems but individual citizens may.” So, are current alternatives like low-cost computer-based services an acceptable solution to those in need? For many average Americans the answer is “only in some cases” according to the DRI poll. Likewise, the overwhelming number of average Americans still want human beings adjudicating their cases.

The poll of more than 1,400 households was conducted by AmeriSpeak, a polling firm funded and operated by NORC at the University of Chicago.  AmeriSpeak® is a probability-based panel designed to be representative of the US household population. Randomly selected US households are sampled with a known, non-zero probability of selection from the NORC National Sample Frame, and then contacted by US mail, email, telephone, and field interviewers (face to face). AmeriSpeak panelists participate in NORC studies or studies conducted by NORC on behalf of governmental agencies, academic researchers, and media and commercial organizations.

###

About DRI – The Voice of the Defense Bar

For more than fifty-five years, DRI has been the voice of the defense bar, advocating for 22,000 defense attorneys, commercial trial attorneys, and corporate counsel and defending the integrity of the civil judiciary. A thought leader, DRI provides world-class legal education, deep expertise for policy-makers, legal resources, and networking opportunities to facilitate career and law firm growth. For more information, log on to www.dri.org

DRI National Poll: Average Americans Not Yet Willing to Entrust Their Legal Fate to Computers or Non-Lawyer Assistants

  • Published February 20, 2018
    Modified July 09, 2020

 

CHICAGO ­– (February 19, 2018)—The only national poll of average Americans on the civil justice system has found the majority of them are not willing to rely on either computers or non-lawyer assistants for legal advice. This is the conclusion obtained in the latest DRI National Poll on the Civil Justice System conducted in December by AmeriSpeak, a polling firm of NORC at the University of Chicago.

The poll results are highly relevant to the legal profession and the judicial system given the conversation surrounding the application of artificial intelligence and the rise of low-cost legal counseling services that employ non-lawyer assistants.

“There are many consumers of legal services in the U.S.” says DRI president John Kuppens. “Because most of the debate about the justice system takes place among lawyers, jurists, and policy-makers, DRI thinks it important to find out what the average person thinks  about our civil justice system. You would probably get different answers to our questions if they were being asked of corporate purchases of legal services.”

When asked if they would be comfortable relying on legal advice provided by a computer, two-thirds (66.7%) of those polled said “No.” When asked the same question about receiving legal advice from someone who did not attend law school, the response was overwhelmingly negative (85.4%). Of those that responded “yes” to either question, their confidence was limited to transactional services like preparing a will or handling a real estate closing.

In another question regarding artificial intelligence, respondents were asked if they would rather have their cases decided by a computer generated formula, a judge, a jury, or an arbitrator who may or may not have legal training, The vast majority (87.1%) preferred a judge or jury. Only 5.1% would opt for a computer generated formula.

“This underscores the importance of the DRI poll,” said Steve Puiszis, chair of DRI’s Center for Law and Public Policy. “Without the science of professional polling, any conversation about consumer preferences on legal services and other aspects of the judicial system are just a matter of speculation or personal bias. The DRI poll is a scientific reflection of popular opinion.”

Puiszis noted “there are important societal questions reflected in the DRI poll. All stakeholders in our civil justice system should be concerned about access to justice for those who need it. Corporations generally don’t have access to justice problems but individual citizens may.” So, are current alternatives like low-cost computer-based services an acceptable solution to those in need? For many average Americans the answer is “only in some cases” according to the DRI poll. Likewise, the overwhelming number of average Americans still want human beings adjudicating their cases.

The poll of more than 1,400 households was conducted by AmeriSpeak, a polling firm funded and operated by NORC at the University of Chicago.  AmeriSpeak® is a probability-based panel designed to be representative of the US household population. Randomly selected US households are sampled with a known, non-zero probability of selection from the NORC National Sample Frame, and then contacted by US mail, email, telephone, and field interviewers (face to face). AmeriSpeak panelists participate in NORC studies or studies conducted by NORC on behalf of governmental agencies, academic researchers, and media and commercial organizations.

###

About DRI – The Voice of the Defense Bar

For more than fifty-five years, DRI has been the voice of the defense bar, advocating for 22,000 defense attorneys, commercial trial attorneys, and corporate counsel and defending the integrity of the civil judiciary. A thought leader, DRI provides world-class legal education, deep expertise for policy-makers, legal resources, and networking opportunities to facilitate career and law firm growth. For more information, log on to www.dri.org

DRI Helps Build Your Book of Business

DRI is the premier global membership organization for legal professionals dedicated to protecting the interests of businesses and individuals in civil litigation. As a member of DRI, you gain exclusive access to a wealth of resources, educational opportunities, and tools. Our mission is to empower attorneys committed to delivering top-notch, fair, and outstanding legal services to their clients and corporate entities. Join DRI to elevate your practice and stay at the forefront of excellence in the legal profession.

Learn More

Drive Your Business with Referrals

Two hands shaking icon diversity

47% of DRI members have given or received a referral in the last 2 years.

Of Those Receiving Referrals

79% Have received 2 or more referrals in the last 2 years

51% Were more than $50K

Of Those Giving Referrals

80% Have given 2 or more referrals in the last 2 years

52% Were more than $50K

Based on a 2024 survey of active DRI members.

Explore the Benefits of DRI Membership

Attendees networking at a conference

Seminars + Networking Opportunities

Attend an in-person event to grow your book of business, sharpen your professional skills, and earn valuable CLE. Members receive the lowest pricing!

Woman working from home with laptop and taking notes

Webinars

Take advantage of webinars on trending topics from leaders in the field. Plus, DRI Members receive 9 free webinars in 2024. Earn up to 8 CLE (value $1,350)!

Laptop opened with headphones and glasses on table

On-Demand Library

Earn CLE credit anytime and anywhere through DRI's On-Demand Library, with over 150 available programs.

Man researching and taking notes

Find a Lawyer

Search for lawyers in your area by practice type and committee — and have other lawyers find you.

legalpoint

Publications

DRI members can access our archives and submit articles for consideration, allowing them to share their professional expertise with colleagues across the globe.

Corinthian Columns Courthouse

Courtroom Insight (DRI Expert Database)

Searching for an expert witness? Browse from over 460,000 profiles as you research your case.

Meet Our Premier Corporate Partner

LawyerGuard Logo

DRI would like to recognize and thank our Premier Corporate Partner for their support in helping to shape the future of civil litigation.

Get Involved by Joining a Committee

Group of people brainstorming ideas

Joining any of DRI’s 30 committees is a great way to engage with the community, enhance your career, and grow your network. A number of the committees also have “specialized litigation groups” (SLGs) that focus on specific areas of practice. FREE for DRI Members.

Explore our Committees

DRI Helps Members Succeed

Douglas Burrell

"DRI helped me expand my network to obtain business referrals from other attorneys. If you put in the effort, DRI will certainly work for you."

Douglas Burrell, Chartwell Law

Catherine Leatherwood

"Starting my DRI involvement as a Young Lawyer has provided me with all these benefits and so many more. It has truly enhanced my career and my development as a lawyer."

Catherine Ava Leatherwood, Rogers Townsend LLC

Erik W. Snapp

"DRI is more than just a group that provides high-quality programming -- it’s a community of friends and soon-to-be friends who work together and learn from each other."

Erik W. Snapp, Eli Lilly and Company

Are You Ready to Grow Your Career?

Get Started!